Velina Tchakarova on China, Russia, and the Future of Geopolitics
Conversations with TylerWed Jun 12 2024
Balkan Wars and Their Relevance Today:
- The Balkan Wars remain significant due to the concept of Balkanization, where countries are divided for external powers to interfere.
- Nationalist sentiments from these wars persist in political groups and parties in the region, influencing agendas and narratives.
- Recent incidents like the Iranian helicopter crash are being compared to historical events like the Sarajevo moment, highlighting ongoing tensions.
Future of Bulgarian Nationalism:
- Bulgarian nationalism has historical roots but is unlikely to lead to dreams of a greater Bulgaria due to demographic collapse, migration trends, and low birth rates.
- Nationalistic sentiments will continue but may not find common ground among the population as aspirations for territorial expansion diminish.
Influence of External Powers on Eastern European Countries:
- Geographic proximity plays a role in predicting which Eastern European nations remain closer to Russia or China.
- Cultural, personal, religious, and post-imperial ties influence relationships with external powers like Russia.
- Perception can differ from reality; for example, Serbia perceives Russian investment highly despite EU being the largest investor.
China's Strategy Towards Taiwan:
- China is more likely to use subtle methods like political penetration rather than direct military attack on Taiwan.
- A slow approach through societal subversion could be more effective than risking a military intervention with uncertain outcomes.
International Law and Global Conflicts:
- International law faces challenges in an evolving global system where power dynamics often override legal norms.
- Lack of a global enforcer leads to increased military conflicts worldwide despite existing legal frameworks.
Putin's Potential Future Actions After Ukraine:
- Putin aims for full control over Ukraine and may continue aggressive actions if successful in gaining territory.
- Possible future targets include Moldova, Georgia, or Baltic states depending on regional stability and support from allies like China.
Speculation on Nuclear Weapon Use:
- Risk of nuclear weapon use remains low despite geopolitical tensions.
- North Korea is less likely to use nuclear weapons due to repercussions from major players like China and Russia.
- Middle East might witness increased nuclearization given Iran's progress towards acquiring nuclear capabilities.
Global System Concept and Foresight vs. Predictions:
- Foresight involves categorizing events into trends to assess possible trend projections, focusing on the macro perspective of the global system.
- The speaker distinguishes foresight from predictions, emphasizing that they anticipate possible futures rather than forecast them.
- The concept of a global system encompasses relevant socioeconomic networks like finance, trade, energy, and agriculture that have become intertwined due to globalization.
- Most analysts have historically pointed towards multipolarity in geopolitics; however, the speaker challenges this notion by arguing that there are only two centers of power with other countries oscillating between the United States and China.
Geopolitical Dynamics - China-Russia Axis:
- Russia has aligned with China since 2014, benefiting from their relationship during economic challenges.
- Middle powers like India act as geopolitical bridges between major powers to capitalize on both worlds without taking sides.
- The speaker introduces the Dragon Bear concept representing coordination between China and Russia without a formal alliance.
- Recent discussions about decoupling and bipolarity in relation to China-Russia relations highlight the evolving dynamics in geopolitics.
Challenges of Long-Term Projections and Geopolitical Foresight:
- It is challenging to integrate long-term trend projections into daily politics due to time constraints and complexities involved in understanding systemic processes.
- Providing foresight for clients involves preparing them for long-term perspectives rather than daily briefs or country-specific analyses.
- Developing unbiased methodologies for geopolitical foresight requires freeing oneself from personal biases and establishing qualitative models based on observations rather than empirical metrics.