Image of podcast

DEBATE: Liberalism Vs Conservatism

TRIGGERnometry

Fri Nov 10 2023



Liberalism and Civic Peace:

  • Liberalism aims to achieve civic peace, but recent events have raised questions about the presence of such peace.
  • The focus on individual freedom within liberalism can lead to a lack of cohesive societal structure, potentially contributing to social unrest.

Conservatism and Tradition:

  • Conservatism emphasizes preserving traditions and established hierarchies as a means of maintaining stability in society.
  • It resists rapid change due to the belief that accumulated wisdom within tradition holds value and should not be disregarded hastily.

Epistemological Differences:

  • Conservatives prioritize slow, cautious change rooted in historical knowledge and traditional values, while liberals advocate for more progressive, immediate shifts based on new ideas and rationality.
  • This epistemological divergence leads to moral conflicts regarding the pace of societal transformation and the acceptance of new ideologies or beliefs.

Challenges with Rapid Change:

  • Conservatives are wary of abrupt alterations that challenge long-standing traditions, expressing concern about subverting accumulated wisdom without fully understanding its implications.
  • There is a moral objection from conservatives towards sudden ideological shifts which disregard established norms and historical significance.

Epistemological differences between conservatism and liberalism:

  • Rationality is dispersed in various ways, including the price mechanism and common law.
  • The conservative approach emphasizes respect for accumulated moral wisdom over time, advocating for an adaptive method that acknowledges the lack of omniscient clarity.

Influence of technology on societal change:

  • Technology has had a significant impact on societal changes, such as enabling the sexual revolution through advancements like the pill and bringing about radical transformations with inventions like the washing machine.
  • Louise Parrott's point about technological advancements facilitating societal shifts is highlighted, along with Mary Harrington's observation regarding the transformative effects of inventions.

Freedom within a political context:

  • The discussion addresses complexities related to individuals in the transgender movement seeking freedom from biological constraints.
  • There is a nuanced exploration of freedom within a political context, distinguishing it from metaphysical concepts like biology or physics and highlighting the distinction between social and political concepts of freedom.